Is Wild Goat the Most Organic Meat in the World?

West Coast councillor Andy Campbell wants pest deer and goats eaten, not left to rot, and called wild goat "probably the most organic meat in the world". He's onto something. Just not organic.

Share
Is Wild Goat the Most Organic Meat in the World?
Photo by Ray Aucott / Unsplash

West Coast regional councillor Andy Campbell has a plan for the region's feral goats. Eat them. The regional council is reviewing its pest management plan and weighing up whether to list feral goats, pigs and deer as pests for eradication. Campbell would rather they were harvested for food than left to rot on the forest floor, with ratepayers footing the bill. New Zealand imports goat meat, he pointed out, and there are enough people here to eat the ones we've got. Then came the line that made the headlines. Wild goat, he said, is "probably the most organic meat in the world".

It's a good line. It's also wrong, though not for the reason you'd expect. Pulling it apart turns up three smaller stories, about hunting, poison and goats, and they're all more interesting than the quote.

The good old days of the deer wars

Campbell's argument leans on history. Back in the 1960s and 70s, he said, deer were hunted from helicopters and "there wasn't a deer problem". In an earlier interview in November 2025, the dairy farmer went further. He credited the wild venison export trade with keeping numbers down, and blamed DOC's switch to 1080 for ending that trade almost overnight.

The helicopter era was real, and it was wild. According to Te Ara, more than 60 helicopters were shooting and recovering deer by 1970, and most crews brought out over 100 deer a day. When the price of wild venison hit $1 a pound in July 1973, it set off a "venison rush". Twenty to thirty helicopter crews made illegal raids into Fiordland National Park, and there were helicopters shot at from the ground, arson, sabotage and fist fights. The government eventually sent in air-force helicopters to calm things down. New Zealand's version of the Wild West, with venison instead of gold.

What ended it is less clear-cut than Campbell suggests. Manaaki Whenua Landcare Research puts the wild harvest peak at about 133,000 deer in 1972. By the early 1980s it had fallen to about 45,000, when helicopters switched to catching deer alive to stock the new deer farms. The researchers say demand for wild deer depends largely on how well farmed deer can supply the market. By 2015, meat inspectors were processing 421,108 farmed deer and 16,842 wild ones. Their account doesn't mention 1080 at all. Deer farming, on that account, ate the wild trade's lunch.

Meanwhile, the deer kept breeding. DOC now estimates there are over 1 million wild deer in New Zealand, adding more than 300,000 a year. It says recreational hunting alone often isn't enough to bring numbers down far enough for forests to recover.

You can eat it. You can't sell it.

Here's the snag in "just eat them". A hunter can shoot a wild goat and feed it to the family. Selling it is another matter.

MPI's rules are blunt. Recreationally hunted meat can't be sold under any circumstances. You can't barter it, raffle it, donate it to a fundraiser, serve it to paying guests at a lodge, or sell it at a wild food festival. You can sell the skin and the antlers, just not the steak. Break the trade ban and the maximum fine is $75,000 for an individual and $300,000 for a company.

Wild meat can only be bought and sold if both the hunter and the processor are certified by MPI. To get listed, a commercial hunter has to pass a food safety test and re-sit it every two years, and work to an operations manual their processor has signed off. So eating the West Coast's pests at any scale means running them through the regulated meat system. And, as it turns out, through the poison rules.

The 1080 problem

If any region tests the "most organic" claim, it's the West Coast. The Environmental Protection Authority's annual report shows the Coast had 25 aerial 1080 operations in 2024, covering 328,542 hectares. That was the largest area of any region, out of just over a million hectares treated nationally.

DOC says it doesn't use 1080 to control deer, goats or pigs. But they are susceptible to it, and DOC sometimes adds deer repellent to the bait in areas with big herds. If a deer, goat or pig eats a bait and survives, DOC says the 1080 breaks down quickly and is excreted within days.

The rules for eating that animal are much more cautious. Under MPI's caution periods, published by DOC, the caution period for 1080 is four months, and for deer and goats it extends to a 2 km buffer zone beyond the operation boundary. DOC's advice is not to eat animals from those areas while the warning signs are up. For brodifacoum, the long-lasting rat poison, the caution period is three years. MPI's own advice to hunters is to skip the offal from wild animals entirely, because poisons can concentrate in the liver and kidneys.

MPI still rates the health risks of eating wild animals as low. But "most organic" is a hard sell for meat from the region with the most 1080 coverage in the country in 2024. Organic farming is built on knowing what went into the animal. With a wild goat on the Coast, you're relying on a map, a date and a warning sign.

Do we really import goat?

Yes, Campbell is right about that, but only just. Trade figures compiled by Tridge show New Zealand imported about 6.7 tonnes of goat meat in 2024, all of it from Australia. In the same year we exported about 697 tonnes, mainly to Canada, Mexico, the United States, France and China.

That's roughly a hundred kilos out for every kilo in. The goat New Zealanders do eat goes mostly to immigrant communities, particularly people from India and Africa, according to Massey University research. The same research notes New Zealand has no specialised goat processing plant.

The bigger hurdle might be taste, or at least reputation. In September, the West Coast branch of the Deerstalkers' Association teamed up with DOC to run a "Bush to Belly" goat cooking day at Punakaiki, as part of the National Wild Goat Competition. Secretary Natassja Savidge said there's "definitely an impression" that wild goat is tough and doesn't taste good. Anyone who has chewed through a badly cooked one won't argue.

So is it organic?

No. And no amount of fresh air will change that.

Under New Zealand's Organic Standards Regulations 2025, which come into force on 31 March 2028, "wild harvest" covers plants, plant products, algae, aquatic plants and fungi. Animals aren't on the list. You can certify wild-picked watercress or seaweed as organic, provided nobody has sprayed the area for at least three years. You can't certify a wild goat. Europe takes the same line. Ireland's food safety authority puts it simply: the products of hunting or fishing wild animals cannot be considered organic.

The reason is the same thing that makes wild goat appealing. Nobody manages it. Nobody can say what it ate, where it wandered, or whether it crossed a baited ridge last month. Organic is a promise about control, and a wild animal is the opposite of controlled.

Campbell's instinct still has something to it. A wild goat gets no drench, no antibiotics, no feed and no fertilised pasture. That's a real point in its favour. It's just not the same point as organic. Call it the most wild meat in the world, and he'd be hard to argue with.

For now, we send about 700 tonnes of goat to Canada and Mexico and buy about seven tonnes from Australia. The regional council is still working out who pays to shoot the rest.


Before you go

If you want more like this in your inbox, sign up free.

If this was useful and you'd like to chip in once, leave a tip.