> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.organicfoodtogether.nz/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Gene-Silencing Bee Treatment the Organic Sector Read About in the Paper
- URL: https://www.organicfoodtogether.nz/the-gene-silencing-bee-treatment-the-organic-sector-read-about-in-the-paper/
- Published: 2026-11-22T17:31:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T17:30:59.000Z
- Description: A varroa treatment that silences genes in the mite was field-trialled in hives in both islands. New Zealand's organic rules list gene silencing as prohibited. OANZ ran a webinar on what it has found, and what nobody has answered yet.
- Author: Luke Nicholas
- Tags: gene technology bill, pesticides, honey, regulation, OANZ, News

---

**The short version**

New Zealand's organic sector found out from a newspaper. A new kind of pest treatment, one that works by switching off genes inside the pest, had already been field-trialled in beehives in both islands. OANZ, the sector's national body, had members farming near the trial sites. Nobody told them.

New Zealand's organic rules treat gene silencing as genetic engineering and ban it. The regulator doesn't. It classes these products as chemicals, which sends them down a different approval path from GMOs, one where trials don't have to be made public and the results stay private for commercial reasons.

OANZ is now trying to find out how many of these products are being tested, where, and by whom, so the risks can be properly assessed.

Here's what it has found so far.

---

The newspaper was Farmers Weekly, and it was read over a cup of tea. That's how Brendan Hoare, an advisor to OANZ, told it at the start of a webinar on 19 November 2026\. The article was a few pages in, under a heading about biopesticides. It was about Norroa, a treatment for the varroa mite that kills honey bee colonies, and it said the research included field trials. OANZ's briefing note dates the article to 17 June 2026 and says the lead researcher was Professor Phil Lester of Victoria University of Wellington, who explained that Norroa uses double-stranded RNA to make the mite sterile.

It isn't the most reassuring notification system. But it worked.

## What dsRNA actually does

Double-stranded RNA, or dsRNA, is the molecule behind a process called RNA interference. Dr Elvira Dommisse, OANZ's science advisor, explained it in the webinar as a switch: it turns a targeted gene off, so the protein that gene would normally make never gets made. In Norroa's case the target is a gene the varroa mite needs to reproduce. The researchers' own project summary says mites and bees both survived treatment in their work, but [the mites stopped reproducing](https://data.bioheritage.nz/dataset/7f011462-5f50-4c6a-aa7f-a5171d9becab/resource/ba5b3a3f-6578-49dc-8091-7f425129b807/download/so5-varroa-2.pdf?ref=organicfoodtogether.nz). The treatment is fed to the bees in sugar water.

Dommisse's concern is what else gets switched off. She told the webinar that genes with similar sequences, in the target or in anything else that comes into contact with the product, can be affected too, and that the effects can be passed to the next generation. Her example was a dsRNA product used against plant hoppers on US crops, where a spider that preys on the hoppers was harmed after drinking water droplets from treated plants. She also pointed out two contradictions she expects industry to argue: that RNA is everywhere and harmless, while the product is designed to be toxic to a pest; and that RNA breaks down quickly, while the product is formulated to stay stable.

Some background on Dommisse is worth having here. Before this work, she spent eight years at Crop & Food Research, where she did her PhD and set up the onion genetic modification programme. She told the audience she hasn't worked on dsRNA herself and is learning from the literature and from people like Professor Jack Heinemann.

## Why organic growers care

This isn't a matter of opinion for certified organic operators. It's written into New Zealand's own organic rules. Clause 1.2(1)(c) of the Organic Notice: Operators 2026, made under the Organic Standards Regulations 2025, lists gene silencing among the technologies that must not be used in organic production or processing. OANZ's briefing note says the notice was made on 10 August 2026 and comes into force on 31 March 2028.

Norroa works by RNA interference. RNA interference is gene silencing.

The briefing note is also honest about the soft spots. The same clause exempts livestock vaccines made with prohibited techniques, and OANZ expects someone to argue that a varroa treatment deserves the same pragmatism. And dsRNA drifting from a trial onto an organic property wouldn't automatically be a breach for that grower. That's why OANZ says organic operators need to know where the trials are, so they can take reasonable steps.

## What has been trialled, and where

The Norroa trials are the ones with the most detail. In the webinar, Scott Lawson, an OANZ board member, said OANZ only found out recently that trials had been run near Ashburton and in the Manawatū, between Palmerston North and Feilding, where OANZ has members with certified organic farms. Brendan Hoare told the audience the Norroa trial started and finished in 2023\. The researchers' project summary gives a longer window: it says they ran field trials [from 2022 to 2024, in hundreds of hives across both islands](https://data.bioheritage.nz/dataset/7f011462-5f50-4c6a-aa7f-a5171d9becab/resource/ba5b3a3f-6578-49dc-8091-7f425129b807/download/so5-varroa-2.pdf?ref=organicfoodtogether.nz), under an EPA permit and a provisional registration from MPI.

There's a commercial partner. Lawson said the Norroa work is funded in part by GreenLight Biosciences, a US company. The researchers' summary says GreenLight has submitted the product for registration in the United States and wants to look at registering it for New Zealand beekeepers.

Then there's the wider picture. OANZ's briefing note cites an Official Information Act request reporting that the EPA had permitted 102 new experimental pesticides for glasshouse and field trials, with the compounds not disclosed, and that some are suspected to be dsRNA. In the webinar, Lawson put the current figure at 104, and said most of them are replicates built on two active ingredients. One is a new dsRNA product for grapevines that sits with the Bragato Research Institute, the wine industry's research body. Hoare said it has been approved for field trials but not yet used.

## Why it's treated as a chemical, not a GMO

This is the part that trips everyone up. Hoare said OANZ has been told dsRNA products are being handled under the Hazardous Substances and New Organisms Act as hazardous substances, not new organisms. That puts them in the same regulatory lane as an agrichemical. Lawson explained what that means in practice: the EPA decides whether a trial is publicly notified, trials generally aren't, and the results aren't public either, for reasons of commercial sensitivity.

Dommisse's way of describing the problem was that dsRNA is a mobile genetic element applied as a substance. It gets classed by how it's applied rather than by what it does once it's inside an organism. OANZ wants it treated as a new organism. Her suggested compromise was to call it both: a hazardous substance that creates new organisms.

OANZ's briefing note asks why some uses of dsRNA have been exempt from regulation since 2019\. The note also says this was never made clear at any of the three Select Committee processes on the Gene Technology, HSNO Amendment and ACVM Amendment Bills, all of which OANZ opposed. Lawson told the webinar the ACVM Bill has since passed.

## The researchers' side

The people running the Norroa work have answered some of this, at least in part. At a 2022 webinar, they said they had [full regulatory oversight](https://bioheritage.nz/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/QA-SO5inv-webinar.pdf?ref=organicfoodtogether.nz) through the EPA under the HSNO Act and MPI under the ACVM Act. They said they had searched genomics databases for species with similar genes and hadn't found any with the same sequence, and that a lab trial on bumble bees was under way. Their project summary says bees, bumble bees and wax moths don't appear to be affected, and that their analysis suggests only species closely related to varroa would likely be hit.

They also said, plainly, that they couldn't rule out other species being affected. They flagged pseudoscorpions living in hives as one they couldn't assess, because nobody knows those animals' genomes.

## What nobody knows yet

Plenty. OANZ has no comprehensive list of trial sites. It doesn't know how many of the approvals involve formulations designed to last longer in the environment or get into cells more easily, a question raised by an audience member that Dommisse said matters because it increases exposure. And there's no answer on who pays if an organic grower is contaminated. Lawson said liability was one of the issues OANZ contested on the Gene Technology Bill, and its position all along has been to keep this kind of work in the lab.

One of the open questions is the honey. Hoare said OANZ has asked twice what happened to the honey and the hives from the Norroa trials, and was still waiting for an answer. The researchers' 2022 answers give part of one: the trial required [honey from treated hives to be burned](https://bioheritage.nz/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/QA-SO5inv-webinar.pdf?ref=organicfoodtogether.nz), and they suggested applying the treatment in autumn, after harvest, to limit dsRNA in honey once it's in use. Bees forage up to around five kilometres, someone called out during the webinar, which is the reason the trial locations matter to neighbours.

## What OANZ is asking for

OANZ wants all trials stopped until there's a full inquiry into how much dsRNA is in use and whether any part of the EPA process was breached. It wants dsRNA and new breeding techniques regulated as gene technologies, and the Gene Technology, HSNO and ACVM bills treated as one package. It has asked for a government group across agencies that includes the organic sector, and it has a further OIA request in to find out which of the experimental pesticides contain dsRNA, where they're being tested, and who is doing it.

Lawson was clear that OANZ's dealings with MPI and the EPA have been better than expected. Hoare went further in the EPA's defence: he doubted the agency even knew the organic act existed, let alone that gene silencing is banned under it. MPI, which runs the organic act, hadn't known the EPA was running the trials.

Two agencies, one kitchen table, one copy of Farmers Weekly. As of 19 November, the honey question had been asked twice and was still waiting.

The full recording is on OANZ's YouTube channel, along with [a link to its briefing note](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zoTZ7PsG1uVO%5FUGHSuxQf2K69n3g12EF/view?ref=organicfoodtogether.nz)

\[Webinar Recording\] dsRNA Trials in NZ and their implications for primary production.

---

**Before you go**

If you want more like this in your inbox, [sign up free](https://www.organicfoodtogether.nz/#/portal/signup).

If this was useful and you'd like to chip in once, [leave a tip](https://www.organicfoodtogether.nz/#/portal/support).